On October 27, 1988, the quiet Florida communities of Columbia County and Suwannee County were devastated by two shocking crimes — the disappearance of Detra and Roshanda McGuire and the murder of businessman John W. Dwight. More than three decades later, these heartbreaking cases remain unsolved mysteries, leaving families and communities searching for justice.
Remembering the Young Victims of 9/11: Honoring the Lives of Eight Children Lost in the Tragedy
The Disappearance of Detra and Roshanda McGuire
On that fateful day, Detra McGuire and her young daughter Roshanda McGuire left home to run a small errand but never returned. Days later, Roshanda’s body was discovered along the side of Interstate 10, confirming investigators’ worst fears. Detra, however, was never found. Authorities suspect foul play, but despite years of investigation, Detra’s disappearance remains a cold case.
Over 35 years later, the McGuire family continues to seek answers and hopes someone will finally come forward with vital information that could lead to closure.
The Murder of Businessman John W. Dwight
Five years after the McGuire tragedy, another horrific event occurred in Suwannee County. Prominent Live Oak businessman John W. Dwight was brutally beaten and shot near the Live Oak Gas Company, where he worked. Evidence suggests that at least two individuals were involved in his murder, which took place between 2:00 and 4:00 PM during his lunch break.
Despite clear signs of a violent struggle and numerous leads, Dwight’s case remains unsolved. His family has spent decades waiting for answers and the justice he deserves.
Decades Later: Both Cases Still Unresolved
Though unrelated, the stories of Detra and Roshanda McGuire and John W. Dwight share one painful truth — both remain unsolved. These cases continue to haunt the communities of Columbia and Suwannee Counties. Investigators and family members still hold out hope that someone, somewhere, will finally speak up and bring these cases to a close.
How You Can Help Bring Justice
Authorities urge anyone with information about these cases to come forward. Even a small tip could make a huge difference.
For the McGuire Case:
Columbia County Sheriff’s Office – Det. Sergeant Joshua Green: 386-758-1095
Columbia County Crime Stoppers: 386-754-7099
For the Dwight Case:
Suwannee County Sheriff’s Office – Cpl. Chris Lee: 386-362-2222
Suwannee County Crime Stoppers: 386-208-8477
Conclusion: Justice Still Awaits
Over three decades have passed since these tragedies, but the pursuit of justice continues. By remembering these victims and sharing their stories, we can help keep their cases alive in the public’s memory. Someone knows something — and your voice could be the one that finally brings peace and closure to these grieving families.