A 19-year-old man, Damien Herstel, was charged with murder after a shocking attack inside his Staten Island home on October 6, 2025. The crime occurred in the bathroom of a residence on Carey Avenue in the West Brighton neighborhood, ending in the victim’s death in a gruesome manner.
Public Help Sought in Concern for Safety of Woman in Swadlincote
What Happened
At approximately 4:20 p.m., police responded to a 911 call reporting a violent incident at the Carey Avenue home. Authorities found Herstel had allegedly attacked his mother’s 45-year-old boyfriend with a knife, stabbing him multiple times in the head and neck before decapitating him. The victim’s head was reportedly found in the bathtub, with the weapon still protruding from his neck.
Herstel’s 16-year-old sister arrived home from school to a horrifying scene: her brother covered in blood and the home soaked in it. Discovering the victim, she immediately called her mother, who ran home and called 911. Witnesses reported hearing the mother screaming, “He’s dead! He’s dead!”
After the attack, Herstel surrendered peacefully to police, walking with officers to a nearby ambulance. Authorities said Herstel appeared emotionally disturbed and was taking medication for emotional issues. He was taken to the hospital before being arraigned in court.
Background of the Incident
Police records indicate a troubled relationship between Herstel and his mother’s boyfriend. Several incidents had been reported in the past:
- 2021: Herstel’s mother reported her boyfriend for drinking and alleged the presence of guns in the home. No weapon was recovered.
- August 2023: An altercation where the boyfriend allegedly slapped Herstel and attempted to attack the mother. Police were called, but no clear arrest was reported.
Neighbors expressed shock over the violence. Many said they were unaware of past problems and described the attack as “satanic” and “evil,” expressing disbelief that such brutality could occur in their quiet neighborhood.
Police Investigation
Following the attack, Herstel’s mother told police her son had special needs and urged officers not to harm him. Witnesses stated Herstel appeared “relieved” after the incident but showed no visible emotion during his arrest.
Detectives are continuing their investigation, focusing on the motive behind the attack and the family’s history of reported incidents.
Public Reaction
The murder has left the Staten Island community stunned. Locals and neighbors expressed sorrow and disbelief, with discussions emerging about the dangers of domestic violence, untreated mental health issues, and family conflict. This incident has also sparked debate over how such disputes escalate to extreme violence.
Conclusion
Damien Herstel remains in custody, facing charges of second-degree murder and related crimes. Police are continuing to examine the circumstances surrounding this tragic incident and the family’s history to better understand what led to the brutal attack.