Officials in Cardogan Township, Pennsylvania, report that 39-year-old Jessica Mary Muth has been jailed without bail after authorities discovered the remains of four infants in her rented home. The tragic discovery occurred following an eviction due to unpaid rent.
Memphis Teen Addison Cook Found Safe After Running Away from DCS Facility
What Happened
The investigation began on August 30, 2025, when landlord Brent Frenoligan changed the locks on Muth’s home. While preparing the property for a new tenant, Frenoligan and a worker noticed a strong odor emanating from a garbage bag inside a bedroom cupboard. Upon inspection, they discovered the remains of an infant and immediately contacted authorities.
Further investigation and interviews revealed a total of four deceased infants hidden in the home, including locations such as the attic.
Charges Against Jessica Muth
Jessica Muth has been charged with:
- Four counts of criminal homicide
- Involuntary manslaughter
- Four counts of concealing the death of a child
- Four counts of abuse of a corpse
Who Is Jessica Muth
Muth lived in the rented house with her two young sons, ages 6 and 8. Her husband, Jacob Muth, is serving a prison sentence for DUI and child welfare concerns. The two living children are now in the care of extended family.
Background and Allegations
According to affidavits, Muth admitted to giving birth alone on at least two occasions. In one instance, she reportedly wrapped a newborn in a towel and placed the body in a bag after it stopped breathing. In another, she allegedly discovered her child deceased shortly after birth.
Officials believe the births may have occurred over several years, possibly dating back six years. None of the births or deaths were reported, and investigators are reviewing medical records and speaking with family and acquaintances to understand the full circumstances.
Public and Community Reaction
The case has shocked the Cardogan Township community, located approximately 35 miles north of Pittsburgh. Neighbors expressed disbelief that such incidents went unnoticed for so long. Many have also voiced concern for the safety and well-being of Muth’s surviving children.
What Happens Next
Jessica Muth remains in Armstrong County Jail without bail and is expected to appear in court on Monday. State police continue to investigate to determine the timeline of the births and deaths and whether additional charges may follow.
Conclusion
The discovery of four deceased infants in a home following an eviction is a deeply tragic and unsettling case. Authorities are working to uncover the full circumstances, while the community rallies to support the surviving children and address the shock of this shocking revelation.