A 76-year-old woman in Long Island is facing legal trouble after shooting her neighbor with a flare gun during a heated argument in her retirement community. The incident, which took place on September 8, 2025, in West Babylon, New York, has raised serious concerns about safety and well-being among residents.
David McGurk: A Beloved Husband, Father, Grandfather, and Friend Passes Away
What Happened
Kathleen Shuman, 76, has been accused of attacking her 67-year-old neighbor during a dispute over their pets. According to the police report, the altercation began when tensions flared between the neighbors regarding pet-related issues. Shuman allegedly fired a flare at the man while he was walking his dog, resulting in a facial injury that required six stitches. Both Shuman and her neighbor were taken to the hospital, but thankfully, neither sustained life-threatening injuries.
In response, the neighbor grabbed Shuman’s hair and struck her in the head. He later claimed that his actions were in self-defense, explaining that he was protecting himself and his dog during the confrontation.
Reactions from the Community
The incident has shocked residents of the retirement community, with many expressing concern over the escalating tensions. Several neighbors reported that the man had frequently harassed Shuman, especially due to his dislike of her cat. According to witnesses, Shuman had briefly left the community due to ongoing harassment but returned only to face continued disputes.
The management company overseeing the retirement community expressed its concern over the situation. They assured residents that they are cooperating fully with law enforcement and prioritizing the safety of all members of the community.
What Will Happen Next
Shuman has pleaded not guilty to the charges and is scheduled to appear in court on September 12, 2025. A judge has issued a restraining order, instructing Shuman to avoid contact with her neighbor. Her bail has been set at $5,000.
Conclusion
This is a developing story. We will update this article as more information becomes available. The incident has sparked wider discussions about safety, conflict resolution, and the well-being of elderly residents living in retirement communities.